Rittman Police Chief Robert Shows remains on paid administrative leave as the city continues an investigation stemming from allegations involving his conduct.
Shows has been on leave since Aug. 18. A letter from City Manager Bobbie Beshara notifying Shows of the leave states that he was being placed on paid administrative leave “pending the results of an administrative investigation.”
The city has since provided an anonymous complaint received by Beshara on July 12. The email alleges Shows was involved in an extramarital relationship with a city employee. Importantly, the person who submitted the complaint acknowledged that they could not personally verify the allegation.
Subject: Request for Review of Leadership Conduct
Dear City Manager,
I am writing to express my serious concern regarding allegations involving the Chief of Police. He is allegedly involved in an extramarital relationship with a city employee. I cannot personally verify this information but given the position of public trust held by the Chief, I believe it warrants your attention.
Our community is still grieving the heartbreaking loss of an officer and two other members of our community. During a time when strong, ethical leadership is especially important, any credible allegations involving the conduct of the department’s highest-ranking official have the potential to undermine morale within the department and erode public confidence.
I respectfully ask that you review this matter in accordance with the City’s policies and determine whether further inquiry is appropriate. My intent is not to spread rumors, but to ensure that concerns involving the leadership of the police department are addressed through the proper channels.
If these allegations are accurate, they raise significant questions about leadership, judgment, and accountability within the department.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
The city has not publicly confirmed that an extramarital relationship occurred.
Records obtained from Rittman show Shows’ current employment agreement began Jan. 7, 2026, after he retired and was rehired by the city. The one-year agreement originally ran through Jan. 7, 2027 and paid Shows an annual base salary of $89,290.73.
However, on Sept. 22, Beshara formally invoked a provision of the contract allowing the city to terminate Shows’ employment without cause with 60 days’ written notice.
His final day with the city will be Nov. 22.
Shows will remain on paid administrative leave and continue receiving his contractual pay and benefits through that date. The termination notice also directs him not to conduct city business and to return city-owned property.
Officer Steve Hunter is serving as interim police chief.
The city has provided no public finding from the administrative investigation and has not said whether the allegation in the anonymous complaint has been found to be true.
Rittman Law Director Matthew Simpson confirmed Friday the matter remains under investigation. The city has so far said there are “no additional responsive public records detailing the investigation, its findings or the factual basis for the decision to terminate Shows’ employment.”
Rittman City Council also held a special meeting Friday evening in regard to Shows. Council went into executive session before later adjourning without taking public action or providing additional details.
Additional public-records requests seeking information about the administrative investigation remain pending.
Local news matters.
Wadsworth Community Radio 97.1 FM is a nonprofit, community-powered radio station sharing the stories, voices and updates that keep Wadsworth connected.
A gift of just $5 helps keep local coverage on the air and supports the work we do every day for this community.
Support Wadsworth Community Radio
Follow us on Facebook for more local stories, updates and community coverage: Wadsworth Community Radio on Facebook